Hello dear
Welcome To First Street Apizza
First Street Apizza, located at 21 1st St in Seymour, CT, is a gem for pizza aficionados. Known for its New Haven-style pizza, the restaurant impresses with its consistency in quality and flavor. Signature offerings like the flavorful First St Wings and a variety of fresh and hearty cold subs reflect the commitment to delicious, made-from-scratch food. The inviting atmosphere, complemented by friendly service, makes every visit memorable. From creamy pasta dishes to vibrant salads, each menu item is crafted with care, ensuring a delightful experience. First Street Apizza is a must-try destination that keeps customers returning for more.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Mozzarella Pizza
Tuna Sub
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Turkey Wrap
About
First Street Apizza
Welcome to First Street Apizza, an exceptional gem nestled in the heart of Seymour, Connecticut. This beloved pizza destination has garnered a loyal following for its authentic New Haven-style pizza, solidifying its status as a must-try for both locals and visitors alike. Located at 21 1st St, First Street Apizza offers a welcoming atmosphere complemented by a menu full of delightful food options that go beyond just pizza.
The star of the show, their pizza, boasts a perfectly baked crust—crispy on the outside and delightfully chewy on the inside, forming a satisfying base for a variety of toppings. Locals rave about the overall taste, with many customers noting the solid undercarriage and excellent crisp. The affordable prices make indulging in a few slices an easy decision, whether you're dining solo or sharing a pie with friends and family.
Adding to the experience are the impressive appetizers and sides. Crunchy, golden-brown french fries are seasoned to perfection, tempting even the most discerning fry enthusiasts. If you're feeling adventurous, the stuffed breads offer a savory twist, with options ranging from pepperoni to eggplant, providing a heartwarming companion to your pizza feast. Customers have delighted in the homemade pasta fagioli, an aromatic soup that showcases quality ingredients and loving preparation.
The reviews speak volumes about the friendly staff who create a warm atmosphere that keeps patrons coming back. Diners praise the quick service, highlighting a young team that delivers efficiency with a smile. It’s clear that First Street Apizza is not just about food; it’s about fostering a sense of community and connection through shared meals.
In summary, First Street Apizza encapsulates the essence of a cozy eatery where quality, flavor, and service converge. Whether you're craving a classic slice, a hearty stuffed bread, or a bowl of comforting soup, this local favorite promises a memorable dining experience that will leave you coming back for more. Don’t miss out—stop by and taste the magic for yourself!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I wish these guys delivered to Woodbridge since we are just over the line from Seymour but regardless, the pizza is very good here. We ended up picking up our order and everyone loved the food. Staff was a couple younger guys that were quick and friendly. This will be our new go-to place for pizza. If the owner reads this review, please consier delivering to the Peck Hill area in Woodbridge. ”
“ Not sure how I haven’t found this place sooner but I am impressed. Pizza was definitely a delicious newhavent style pizza. Wings were delicious, flavorful and cooked perfectly and the salad and bread was very fresh! 10/10 recommend. Can’t wait to go back and try more ”
“ These folks make a good pizza, at a fair price. They are consistent when it comes to quality, their staff always seem really enthusiastic, and they don't question odd topping combos. Their storefront isn't the best but it's a pizza joint with an A heath resting. ”
“ Somehow managed to get this far in life without trying (to my recollection) a real New Haven slice. Well today was the day, as I ended up in CT for work and was looking for a quick bite. The pizza was pretty darn good. Solid undercarriage, excellent crisp, and the overall taste was very good. The price (for 2 slices and a drink) was also extremely reasonable. Plus, the guy behind the counter was super friendly. I will definitely be returning if I end up in this area again. I'm sure some would argue that there are better New Haven slices out there but for a first experience, I came away impressed. I would highly recommend this place! ”
“ BETTER THAN MODERN!!! Grew up in CT and always loved any pizza I could get, but the only place I crave when I’m home in Ohio is First Street! Everytime I come back to Connecticut I make sure to eat as much as I can! DO NOT SLEEP ON FIRST STREET!!!!! ”
“ My go to pizza place! Very very similar to New Haven pizza, if not better!!! Staff is extremely friendly as well! Highly recommended ”
“ Good pizza, not necessarily New Haven style, which I expected because they use the term Apizza in the name, but still a 5 star pie. ”
“ What can I say? I am addicted to their The Works pizza. Their menu offers toppings I consider weird, but this combination is strictly main stream. I can't tell you just what they do to make it so very, very good, but I rarely order anything else. They don't just pile on a bunch of stuff, this pie has balance; plenty of toppings but nothing overwhelms anything else. My wife loves The Works too, but will occasionally get one of their clam pies for variety. Their basic cheese pizza is fine too, and that is my own alternative, particularly during the hours of their lunch special. I can't say anything about their delivery service as I always pick it up myself. The staff is always friendly. And man, The Works is just so good! Four years after I wrote the above, I am living half an hour away. Not often, but sometimes I take the drive to Seymour, because it is Just That Good! ”